PAGE 2 CONTINUED FROM PAGE 1
TREMPER-MOUND CITY
PLATFORM PIPES
OHIO
MIDDLE WOODLAND HOPEWELL
2100 TO 1600 YEARS AGO
PAGE 2 OF 2 PAGES
COPYRIGHT DECEMBER 31, 2009 PETER A. BOSTROM

PLASTER CASTS OF HOPEWELL PIPES
MOUND CITY & TREMPER MOUND PIPES

   These pipes were cast from sculpted models copied from Ohio Hopewell pipes. The human effigy pipe in front, the Raven in back at right and possibly another one or two are modeled from Mound City pipes. The other examples are modeled after pipes found at Tremper Mound.

    Perhaps the most important pipes found at Mound City are the human effigy pipes. Although the Tremper collection didn't produce any at all, the Mound City group included four intricately carved and detailed human heads. They are important because they record how the Hopewell were decorating their faces, styling their hair, ornamenting their ears and using different types of headdresses. Shetrone writes about one of the carved heads as being, "one of the finest bits of Mound-builder sculpture extant." He goes on to describe this pipe as, "Note the haughty dignity of the face and the bonnet-like headdress. A chaplet of pearls encircles the forehead, and incised lines probably represent facial painting or tattooing." But it's interesting to note that Squire and Davis evidently had a higher appreciation for a different human effigy pipe as they wrote, "the most beautiful head of the series." and they go on to say "The workmanship of this head is unsurpassed by any specimen of ancient American art which has fallen under the notice of the authors, not excepting the best productions of Mexico and Peru. The whole is smooth and well polished." They are describing the complete example illustrated in this report.


PHOTO BY DENNIS VESPER---OHIO HISTORICAL CENTER COLLECTION
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
HOPEWELL PLATFORM PIPES
TREMPER MOUND
SCIOTO COUNTY, OHIO

     This picture shows many of the best examples of the animal effigy platform pipes that were discovered by Mills during the 1915 excavation of Tremper Mound. The Tremper Mound pipes include sculptured images of owls, hawks, ducks, cranes, quail, prairie chicken, crow, toads, turtles, beaver, otter, mink, raccoon, rabbit, squirrel, porcupine, possum, fox, wolf, bobcat, bear, mountain lion, dog and deer. These pipes are currently on display in the Ohio Historical Center's Museum.

    Some of the Mound City and Tremper pipes were additionally adorned with inlayed copper and pearl. Some of the pipes used either copper or pearls for the eyes. One of the human effigy pipes from Mound City had a row of 15 pearls that were inlayed along the top of the forehead and down both sides of the face to the level of the ears. The inlay was done by drilling small holes as close together as possible and filling each with a pearl. At least one of the human effigy pipes is also reported to have had copper earrings. Yet another use of copper, although not decorative, is reported as thin bands that were used to repair broken pipes, which is an indication that some of the pipes were in use before they were ritually destroyed.


PHOTO BY DENNIS VESPER---OHIO HISTORICAL CENTER COLLECTION
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
PLATFORM PIPES
TREMPER MOUND CACHE
SCIOTO COUNTY, OHIO

   The 1915 Tremper Mound excavation also produced several platform pipes with simple round bowls with flared rims. The majority of the Tremper Mound pipes were carved in various types of pipestone. It was generally believed that all of the Tremper pipes were carved from Ohio pipestone. But Emerson reports that, of the Tremper pipes sampled and tested with a portable infrared mineral analyzer system, 16% of the pipes were made from Catlinite from the pipestone quarries in southwest Minnesota. Although there is a good source of pipestone only a few miles away to the east of the site, this is another example of how the Hopewell culture often preferred the use exotic materials from distant locations. All of the platform pipes in this picture are on display in the Ohio Historical Center's collection. They represent the largest pipes in the Tremper Mound cache of pipes.

    The Mound City and Tremper pipes were made from soft stones that were carved with stone tools. One of the more exotic stone and possibly the rarest example was a Tremper Mound bird effigy platform pipe carved in fossil coral. The majority of the pipes were carved in various types of pipestone. It was generally believed that all of the Tremper pipes were carved from Ohio pipestone. But Emerson reports that, of the Tremper pipes sampled and tested with a portable infrared mineral analyzer system, 16% of the pipes were made from Catlinite from the pipestone quarries in southwest Minnesota. Although there is a good source of pipestone only a few miles away to the east of the site, this is another example of how the Hopewell culture often preferred the use exotic materials from distant locations.


PHOTO BY DENNIS VESPER---OHIO HISTORICAL CENTER COLLECTION
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR LARGER IMAGE
BIRD EFFIGY PLATFORM PIPE
TREMPER MOUND CACHE
SCIOTO COUNTY, OHIO

    The haunting appearance of this Tremper Mound effigy pipe comes from the individual polyps in the fossil coral limestone that it was made from. Fossil coral may be the most exotic stone that was used to make the Tremper Mound pipes. The bird is identified as an eagle but it's obvious that it is a raptor. This pipe is the largest of the bird effigy pipes. It measures 4 3/4 inches (12.1 cm) long. This pipe is on display in the Ohio Historical Center's museum in Columbus, Ohio.

    The Tremper Mound site consists of one irregularly shaped mound approximately eight to nine feet in height and measures about 120 feet wide and 250 feet long. The mound is surrounded by a slightly oval embankment measuring 400 feet by 500 feet.


PHOTO BY DENNIS VESPER---OHIO HISTORICAL CENTER COLLECTION
PLATFORM BIRD EFFIGY PIPE
TREMPER MOUND CACHE
SCIOTO COUNTY, OHIO

    This Tremper Mound pipe is on display in the Ohio Historical Center's museum in Columbus, Ohio. This pipe is exceptionally well made. The raptorial bird is fully carved standing on its two legs. Even the claws are represented on the base of the platform. The pipe also has one additional unique decoration in the form of copper inlays for the eyes.

    The Mound City site is contained within 13 acres that is surrounded by a rectangular low embankment. There are 23 mounds within the rectangular enclosure. In fact, the site received its descriptive name from the high concentration of mounds within such a small area.

Early map of Tremper Mound by Charles Whittlesey.
ILLUSTRATION FROM 1848 "ANCIENT MONUMENTS OF THE MISSISSIPPI VALLEY"
CLICK ON PICTURE FOR FULL MAP
EARLY MAP OF TREMPER MOUND
FROM SQUIRE & DAVIS
HOPEWELL SITE
SCIOTO COUNTY, OHIO

    This is a map of the Tremper Mound site. It was published in 1848 by Squire and Davis in "Ancient Monuments of the Mississippi Valley." The Tremper Mound site consists of one irregularly shaped mound approximately eight to nine feet in height and measures about 120 feet wide and 250 feet long. The mound is surrounded by a slightly oval embankment measuring 400 feet by 500 feet.

     It's interesting to note that many of the mound sites surveyed and described by Squire and Davis have been as Romain writes,"----extensively destroyed, we will probably never know their exact size." As an example, the Mound City site was selected to become Camp Sherman, a large military training center. Several of the mounds were leveled to make room for buildings. But the rest of the mounds were saved with a last minute plea from the Ohio State Museum. The camp was later dismantled after the war and the land was turned over to the Ohio Archaeological and Historical Society by the War Department. However, in this case, the mounds and earthworks were actually restored as Shetrone writes, "to their former condition."


PHOTO BY BILL FECHT and DENNIS VESPER----CLEM CALDWELL COLLECTION
OWL EFFIGY PLATFORM PIPE
KNIGHT SITE
CALHOUN COUNTY, ILLINOIS

    This picture shows another example of a Hopewell effigy platform pipe. The full standing bird on this pipe is an owl. It was once in the Dr. Titterington collection and is known as the "Titterington pipe." The pipe is shown how it was once displayed on Clem Caldwell's cabinet shelf and another picture of the side taken by a different photographer. Note the engraving of the feet, feathers and carved features of the head.

    The Tremper Mound collection of pipes are owned by the Ohio Historical Society in Columbus, Ohio. Many of the better examples are currently on display. The Mound City collection of pipes were dispersed over a wide area. The greater portion of the pipes were sold by Davis to the Blackmore Museum at Salisbury, England who later sold, traded or loaned them to the British Museum in London where many are currently on display. The American Museum of Natural History is reported to have 13 of Squire's pipes, one of which is the human with the 15 inlayed and fragmented pearls.


PHOTO BY BILL FECHT----GILCREASE INSTITUTION COLLECTION
BIRD EFFIGY PLATFORM PIPE

    This Hopewell pipe is reported to have been collected by the Gilcrease Institution by Bill Fecht who took the picture many years ago. Most effigy platform pipes show the various types of animals in a simple poses. But a very few of them, like this example, illustrate the figure as it's involved in some sort of action. They are usually shown eating some type of food. An otter will have a fish in its mouth, a heron will be pecking at a fish or as in this case a little more dramatic, the bird is pecking and eating the human figure.

    If your fortunate enough to see the Mound City or Tremper pipes you'll probably be impressed and agree that they were made by master craftsmen. Although the intention of the original owners were to destroy the pipes by hammer and fire, to either release the object's spirit or to remove any temptation of theft, it's a good bet that most people are thankful that they've been preserved. But you can't help but wonder that there must be some irony in all the intended destruction and ultimate preservation.
LINK TO MORE HOPEWELL PIPES

"REFERENCES"

1848, Squire, E. G. and E. H. Davis, E. H., "Ancient Monuments Of The Mississippi Valley," p. 242-268.
1882
, Barber, Edwin A., "Mound Pipes," The American Naturalist, Vol. XVI, April, pp. 265-268.
1930
, Shetrone, Henry Clyde, "The Mound Builders," pp. 22-24, 122, 162-163, 194-195, 213-214.
1968, Silverberg, Robert, "Mound Builders of Ancient America," pp. 270-273.
2000
, Romain, William F., "Mysteries of the Hopewell," pp. 38 & 209.
2004
, Penney, David W., "The Archaeology of Aesthetics," Hero Hawk and Open Hand,  p. 50.
2005
, Lepper, Bradley T., "Ohio Archaeology," p. 126.
2005
, Emerson, Thomas E., "Tremper Mound, Hopewell Catlinite and PIMA Technology," Mid-Continental Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 30 No. 2, Fall.
Personal Communications with Dennis Vesper.

RECENT LISTINGS    HOME    ORDERING